Smit & Van Wyk Patent, Trademark & Registered Designs

Apple wins Samsung battle in German Court

Intellectual Property Attorneys

Apple is officially the only company that can make and sell minimalist rectangular tablets in Germany. A trade court in Dusseldorf, Germany has found Samsung guilty of violating Apple’s patented iPad design. Presiding Judge Johanna Brueckner-Hofmann remarked upon delivering the verdict that Apple’s minimalistic design isn’t the only technical solution to make a tablet computer, and that other designs are possible.”

Apple filed a patent on the design of the iPad with European Union intellectual property agency in Alicante, Spain. The iPad 2 and Galaxy Tab 10.1 rectangular faces are different and the Samsung device has no physical face buttons, but Apple owns sole rights to “minimalist” tablet designs.

According to the patent

  1. A “minimalist” design is any thin rectangular tablet, with few buttons on its face.
  2. This ruling indicates that Apple has sole rights to make thin rectangular tablets in Germany.

Competitors would have to

  1. Have plenty of physical buttons on the face
  2. Be thicker or heavier than the iPad
  3. Any shape but rectangular

The German court made it clear that the ruling was based solely on the design and had nothing to do with trademarks or patents for technology. Samsung is seeking an expedited appeal in Oberlandesgericht, Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court, that could take 2 to 6 months.

Posted on 14 September 2011
Home / Blog / Apple wins Samsung battle in German Court

Patent Attorneys
It is highly recommended that your claims be written by a qualified patent attorney or patent agent. The patent attorneys at Smit & Van Wyk provide a wide range of patent-related services across multiple industries and fields of technologies, including patent drafting, filing and prosecution.

Mauritius Trademarks
Mauritius trademarks recognise the Nice Classification of goods and services, and allows for multi-class filing. Mauritius trademarks are valid for 10 years from the filing date and renewable for periods of 10 years each upon payment of the renewal fee.

Franchise Attorneys
Franchising legal advice is specialised and differs from other areas of law, thus you need find yourself an attorney that specialises in this specific type of law. Franchise attorneys represent the franchisor, as well as the franchisee. 

PCT National Phase Patents
The PCT National Phase is the second of the two main phases of the PCT procedure. It follows the international phase and consists in the processing of the international application before each Office of (or acting for a Contracting State) that has been designated in the international application.