Smit & Van Wyk Patent, Trademark & Registered Designs

Apple wins Samsung battle in German Court

Intellectual Property Insights

Apple is officially the only company that can make and sell minimalist rectangular tablets in Germany. A trade court in Dusseldorf, Germany has found Samsung guilty of violating Apple’s patented iPad design. Presiding Judge Johanna Brueckner-Hofmann remarked upon delivering the verdict that Apple’s minimalistic design isn’t the only technical solution to make a tablet computer, and that other designs are possible.”

Apple filed a patent on the design of the iPad with European Union intellectual property agency in Alicante, Spain. The iPad 2 and Galaxy Tab 10.1 rectangular faces are different and the Samsung device has no physical face buttons, but Apple owns sole rights to “minimalist” tablet designs.

According to the patent

  1. A “minimalist” design is any thin rectangular tablet, with few buttons on its face.
  2. This ruling indicates that Apple has sole rights to make thin rectangular tablets in Germany.

Competitors would have to

  1. Have plenty of physical buttons on the face
  2. Be thicker or heavier than the iPad
  3. Any shape but rectangular

The German court made it clear that the ruling was based solely on the design and had nothing to do with trademarks or patents for technology. Samsung is seeking an expedited appeal in Oberlandesgericht, Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court, that could take 2 to 6 months.

Posted on 14 September 2011
Home / Intellectual Property Insights / Apple wins Samsung battle in German Court

More Articles

CIPC File Transfer Notice

CIPC File Transfer Notice

Companies and Intellectual Property Commission (CIPC) File Transfer Notice The South African CIPC has commenced with the second stage of the large-scale file transition to a new bulk storage...

Privacy rights in South Africa: Data And Cloud

Privacy rights in South Africa: Data And Cloud

Looking at privacy rights in South Africa with the arrival of the Fourth Industrial Revolution (4IR) we stand at the verge of a technological revolution, characterised by the digitalisation of...


Copyright does NOT have to be registered in South Africa. Unlike patents, trade marks or registered designs, copyright vests in the author of a work once the work is created in a material form. Examples of copyright include: Literary works (eg. novels, poems, textbooks, letters, reports, lectures, speeches), musical works, artistic creations (eg. paintings, sculptures, drawings, photographs), cinematograph films, sound recordings, broadcasts, published editions of books and computer programs.
Read more about Copyright Infringement.

Patent Registration, Patent an Invention, Patent Attorneys, Patent Law
Trademark Registration, Trademark Attorneys, Brand Protection
Registered Designs, Design Patents, Industrial Designs
Copyright Law - Copyright Attorneys - Music Copyright