Smit & Van Wyk Patent, Trademark & Registered Designs

Compensation for digital works

Intellectual Property

An Alternative Compensation System is a proposal for an alternative means for ensuring the authors still receive income from the digitally produced works while the works are digitally produced on a wide scale. Numerous requests and proposals for Alternative Compensation Systems have been made worldwide to adapt to the changing information distribution environment. A less formal proposal for Alternative Compensation Systems entails that of establishing voluntary collective types of licensing. Most of the requests for an Alternative Compensation System, however, involve governments. Peer to peer file sharing is perhaps the most important reason for such proposals as it has become so widespread that it is almost universally acceptable for the users of share systems to do so without considering it as illegal. Many of the proposals suggest taxes on the share systems which could be used for compensation to the authors.

Proposals for such a government driven Alternative Compensation System include targeted levies for digital media players, share systems, and Internet connectivity. The problem still to be addressed then is that a share system operator can avoid paying levies when agreeing not to allow peer to peer sharing. In essence there will always be some form of loophole, depriving the authors and artists of valuable compensation. Another problem still to be addressed regarding the Alternative Compensation Systems is that of distributing the royalties. One agency will have to be in place and with the large number of works produced annually, the agency may easily become overloaded and thus pay out later than should. Yet a further concern is that of fraud and corruption which could leave such an agency useless if it is a government run agency. A final question still to be addressed is how to determine the royalties. Until a workable solution for each of the problems mentioned, is found, the Alternative Compensation System will stay an unimplemented concept.

Posted on 7 March 2011
Home / Copyright / Compensation for digital works

View our Awards & Listings

MIP IP Stars   WTR   Global Chambers   Lexology  I AM PATENT   WWL

Intellectual Property in South Africa

Smit & Van Wyk deals exclusively with patents, designs, trademarks, copyright and plant breeders’ rights in South Africa. Our team of Intellectual Property attorneys have the knowledge, experience and resources to give expert legal advice regarding your Intellectual Property portfolio. We can assist with the protection, prosecution and enforcement thereof. It is our mission to provide unparalleled service to our treasured clients by developing dynamic solutions which are tailored to suit individual Intellectual Property needs. The key to achieving this lies with our vibrant people, who are eager to go beyond the call of duty.

Patent Attorneys
It is highly recommended that your claims be written by a qualified patent attorney or patent agent. The patent attorneys at Smit & Van Wyk provide a wide range of patent-related services across multiple industries and fields of technologies, including patent drafting, filing and prosecution.

South Africa Intellectual Property
Smit & Van Wyk deals exclusively with patents, designs, trademarks, copyright and plant breeders’ rights in South Africa. Our team of Intellectual Property attorneys have the knowledge, experience and resources to give expert legal advice regarding your Intellectual Property portfolio.

Franchise Attorneys
Franchising legal advice is specialised and differs from other areas of law, thus you need find yourself an attorney that specialises in this specific type of law. Franchise attorneys represent the franchisor, as well as the franchisee. 

PCT National Phase Patents
The PCT National Phase is the second of the two main phases of the PCT procedure. It follows the international phase and consists in the processing of the international application before each Office of (or acting for a Contracting State) that has been designated in the international application.